The New England Patriots survived a nail-biting 33-27 win over the Miami Dolphins, but key contributors struggled at critical moments, leaving fans with more questions than answers. Three players stood out with frustrating performances: kicker Andres Borregales, cornerback Alex Austin, and running back TreVeyon Henderson.
K Andres Borregales
The New England Patriots selected Borregales in the sixth round (182nd overall), after a four-year college career at the University of Miami. A former All-ACC kicker and Lou Groza Award semifinalist, Borregales entered the league with a reputation for accuracy and poise under pressure.
After two games, Borregales has yet to find consistency, missing both early extra points against Miami and limiting the Patriots’ lead despite touchdowns on their first two drives. The shaky start could have shifted momentum, but he steadied himself, converting a 22-yard field goal and his extra point following Antonio Gibson’s 90-yard kickoff return touchdown. Finally, with 1:51 left, Borregales converted a 53-yard field goal to give the Patriots some breathing room en route to a 33-27 victory.
Even so, the concerns are real. Borregales is 4 of 5 on field goal attempts and 2 of 4 on extra point attempts. For a rookie kicker on a team that expects to contend, leaving points on the field can’t become a pattern. Special teams coach Jeremy Springer and head coach Mike Vrabel will provide opportunities for improvement, but Borregales must improve his consistency quickly.
CB Alex Austin
Coming into the season, Alex Austin was projected to be the third-string cornerback. But while Christian Gonzalez rehabs his hamstring injury, he has been thrust into the starting lineup opposite Carlton Davis. Against the Dolphins, his limitations were exposed.
With the Pats up 12-0, Austin allowed Jaylen Waddle to slip free for a touchdown that sparked Miami’s offense. The Dolphins' receivers would go on to torch Austin, as he gave up 6 receptions on the day for 98 yards, including the Waddle touchdown. This underwhelming performance earned him a PFF grade of 36.4 and a coverage grade of 38.1. Through two weeks, Alex has an overall grade of 47.0 (114th amongst cornerbacks) and a coverage grade of 46.0 (109th amongst cornerbacks).
When healthy, the Patriots’ cornerback room, anchored by Gonzalez and Davis, is one of the team’s strengths. But without their second-team All-Pro, the lack of depth behind them has become glaring. Austin is being asked to handle matchups well beyond what his role was meant to be.
As his struggles against Miami showed, New England’s secondary is stretched thin. And Austin’s struggles highlight a broader problem: the team’s cornerback depth is limited, leaving the secondary vulnerable until Christian Gonzalez returns. While Austin’s struggles highlighted vulnerabilities in the secondary, the Patriots also faced issues in the backfield, where pass protection became a pressing concern.
RB TreVeyon Henderson
Coming out of Ohio State, TreVeyon Henderson was widely regarded as one of the most versatile running backs in college football. Not only was he productive as a ball carrier, but he also earned praise for his pass protection, route running, and ability to contribute as a receiver out of the backfield. His combination of size, speed, and awareness made him a highly regarded prospect, and many expected him to transition smoothly into a complementary role in the Patriots’ backfield.
The Patriots want to keep franchise quarterback Drake Maye upright, and on Sunday against the Dolphins, Henderson struggled mightily with blitz recognition and pass-blocking assignments. He repeatedly failed to pick up edge rushers, directly contributing to multiple sacks and hurried throws.
Henderson’s blocking struggles limited his snaps, allowing veteran Antonio Gibson—highlighted by a 90-yard kickoff return—to take on a larger role. Henderson’s lack of involvement extended to critical third-down situations, where a reliable pass-blocking back is essential. This limited role diminishes his overall offensive impact, forcing the Patriots to rely more on other backs.
Henderson’s challenges illustrate that the Patriots’ backfield is still a work in progress. Though he has shown flashes of the vision, speed, and agility that made him successful at Ohio State, the transition to the NFL has exposed areas in immediate need of improvement. If he cannot refine his technique and improve his awareness in pass protection, his snaps may continue to decline, and he risks losing a significant role in the offense.
For a team with playoff aspirations and a young quarterback who needs consistent protection, Henderson’s growth—or lack thereof—could have meaningful implications for New England’s offensive success this season.
Individually, Borregales, Austin, and Henderson each faced challenges, but collectively, their inconsistencies underscore that the Patriots have key areas to tighten if they hope to sustain a playoff-caliber season.