It was a risky decision at the time to trade a 2028 first-round pick for a soon-to-be 29-year-old A.J. Brown who a) has a degenerative knee problem, b) wasn't going to stay with the Philadelphia Eagles anyway, and c) wasn't necessarily a hot commodity on the market, and it has gone as poorly as it possibly could have for the New England Patriots up to this point.
A.J. Brown has been a massive disappointment for the Patriots
We are less than two weeks away from Thanksgiving, and the first half of the season is in the books. On the year, Brown has recorded a total of 11 receptions on 26 targets for 128 yards and no touchdowns in parts of four games.
The Mississippi native also drops what feels like every other ball thrown his way, and he has had an incredibly difficult time staying healthy.
He exited the season opener early due to a high-ankle sprain and missed the next four games after being placed on the injured reserve. When he came back, he looked slow and was unproductive. After two games, his knee flared up, and he missed two more games. Then, he made another return on Sunday against the Detroit Lions, brought in just two of his six targets for 27 yards (sure, Tommy DeVito was throwing him the ball, but he still dropped some passes he should have caught), and left the game due to a hamstring injury.
At this point, it wouldn't be a shock if the Patriots choose to keep Brown off the field for the rest of the season, especially since it looks like they could be without Drake Maye for the rest of the year. This trade has been a disaster for New England, and it has only gotten worse with each passing week.
It might be time for Patriots fans to give up on A.J. Brown
Even if Brown recovers from his injuries and rests ahead of next season, that's not going to change the fact that he's going to turn 30 years old in June (which he will likely be the next time he gets to play with Maye and finally develop any sort of connection), and his degenerative knee issue (as the name suggests) is only going to get worse.
The Patriots can't trust that he can be their No. 1 receiver moving forward, and even the idea that his presence alone should open up the field for everyone else on the offense isn't particularly true anymore.
Brown might not be fully washed, but it would be a miracle if New England gets anything close to the player he was even just a couple of years ago. His injury concerns aren't going to get any better, and if this is the "best" physical version of him the Patriots are getting, then there's no reason to believe he will be a big-time contributor moving forward.
